It’s interesting to me how much more challenging it is to work within limits.
Back when I was in high school, I never minded getting essay assignments that had to be at least a certain length. It was never any problem for me to fill out the minimum word count. It’s not that I deliberately padded my papers. My first writing teacher told me I sounded like a nineteenth-century essayist. That’s still true sometimes. I tend to the florid and verbose, and unless I am ruthlessly self-editing I am relentlessly parenthetical.
But when I got to college I started getting assignments with a maximum word count. And my professor was very strict about that – if she said 1,000 words, she meant not one syllable more than 1,000 words. You could lose a letter grade by going over. That nearly drove me crazy.
It forced me to do a lot of editing. I learned to make one word do the work I’d split over several before. I learned to be concise and exact. It was like pulling my own teeth with rusty pliers, but it was worth it. I’m a better writer for learning how to keep it short.
Writing commissioned stories is another challenge. Not only is there the same “keep it under a certain length” challenge and the same “keep it on a set topic” challenge, there’s also the “add these elements” challenge. One of the toughest recently involved writing a 1500-word science fiction story about someone saving the world without knowing it: something Heinlein-ish with robots and the client’s father in it, and it needs to say something about politics or society.
Also I had to juggle three oranges, a chainsaw, and Scarlett Johansson while writing it. And chew gum! Can you imagine? (Okay, I made that up. I didn’t have to chew gum. And there was no mention of juggling fruit, power tools, or actresses. Which is just as well, since I’d have dropped the oranges and the chainsaw for sure.)
I think I managed all but the Heinlein-ish part. And the client was very happy. But it was very tough to come up with a workable idea that could incorporate all that in such a small space. I wasn’t at all sure I could do it, but my Muse came through for me in her usual oblique way – it’s quite a distance from where this story started to where it wound up, both in style and in content. If I didn’t know where it started out, I certainly wouldn’t have been able to guess.
Anyway, it’s good to stretch myself. It’s good to see how I can fill a particular space with my own stuff, even a space I’d never have thought to occupy.
